| commentid | objectid | typeid | userid | subject | comment | timestamp | parentid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15468 | MyLink | games | 506 | Re: MyLink and $CO vs. FSF and Linux | Wrong, or at least not 100% right. Game ideas and game rules are copyrightable, even so it gets a lot more fuzzy what is a infringement and whats not as when somebody simply steals graphics, sounds or code. IIRC Nintendo managed successfully to shutdown Giana Sisters quite a few years ago, which was basically a clone of Super Mario Bros, but with new graphics, sound, music, etc., just a whole number of game ideas where pretty much the same. So if the clone gets really close to the original game it might still end up causing throuble in court. Patents on game ideas are of course also possible in a few countries. After all I would be pretty carefull with exactly cloning games that are still sold and anyway, I consider cloning current games to be a pretty lame thing of doing, since a) you almost never ever reach the original b) you are unfair to the original game author c) you don't really provide anything new. | 2003-11-28 07:39:44 | 15402 |
| 15469 | Battle for Wesnoth | games | 8938 | Great! | Great game, addicitve!<br> Good programming, nice graphics, good music & sounds<br> can't wait to test the multiplayer :)<br> Story & dialogs are somewhat naive, othervise 5 stars.<br> Translations to many languages is nice, you need help with new languages? | 2003-11-28 07:45:57 | 0 |
| 15470 | America's Army: Special Forces | games | -1 | Re: Is armyops a spywhare ? | punkbuster is only there to make sure you dont cheat. it makes sure you dont have a cheating script or sumtin so just play it its fun. | 2003-11-28 08:42:49 | 15461 |
| 15471 | America's Army: Special Forces | games | -1 | Re: Dri | Open drivers have no oil, you see. | 2003-11-28 10:22:17 | 15425 |
| 15472 | America's Army: Special Forces | games | -1 | Re: bush & blair | Sad truth? In a few years from now, when current leaders have safely retired, you'll find out what most of us already know: that everything you heard from government about this was propaganda. What's "true" about that? | 2003-11-28 10:26:43 | 15448 |
| 15473 | America's Army: Special Forces | games | -1 | Re: Americas Army | Uhh... quick hint: this is not a recruiting tool. Neither is it realistic. The only reason for making toys about war is to make people think war is fun. | 2003-11-28 10:28:56 | 15257 |
| 15474 | Excido | games | 8426 | Re: PhysicsFS or more direct compression | First off, physfs isn't a form of compression, it's a library that facilitates the access of game data, including access to various archive formats as well as native filesystem access. In fact, in the way that excido is currently distributed, the sound and graphics sit in the native filesystem. The reason that excido uses physfs is threefold:<ul> <li>I wanted to use it for my own education.</li> <li>I like this kind of packaging paradigm a lot: you can have a number of search paths in an arbitrary order of precedence. In excido, you have the data/ directory and the ~/.excido directory. This allows me to ship a default conf in the data directory, but the altered configuration gets loaded from ~/.excido/excido.conf next time excido starts. It also allows users to install arbitrary data files on a system in which they do not have write access to the directory in which the software is installed.</li> <li>physfs also contributes to making excido more cross platform, since the physfs folks can worry about the various idiosyncracies of the various platforms.</li></ul> <p> SDL_mixer - Yes, I could allow sound to be totally disabled. However, I don't think anyone would want to play without sound. In that scenario, installing SDL_mixer would certainly be the preferable option for the user rather than playing in silence. <p> SDL_image - Playing without textures...interesting concept :-) Dependancy could be removed by packaging bmps, I suppose, rather than pngs. However, I find bmps quite troublesome to manipulate, and this would swell the package size rather a lot. <p> SDL_ttf - I ought to do a nice bitmapped font, I just never got around to it. This is one dep that really shouldn't exist, for performance reasons as well as what we're talking about here. <p> As for including dependencies in the package, I'm not a big fan of that kind of thing. It's something that proprietary distributors do because they have to support the software, including all the libraries they use. I'm not responsible for any of the libs that excido uses, and it would be irresponsible to distribute potentially outdated versions with excido. Also, from the point of view of the user, it's rather annoying to have every SDL (for instance) based game that you install have its own version of the library. <p> For there to be a point in including dependancies, they can't just be the source tarballs that one gets from the project website, they have to be nicely trimmed down source trees, whose make systems have been integrated into the central one. So I would be effectively supporting packages of all of them. Installing binaries is kind of an option, but would only make sense if I was limiting availability to i386 linux users or something. Either that or maintain multiple packages, which is just far too much effort (besides, I don't have a bunch of different platforms kicking around to build stuff on). Platform specific binary packages are something that should generally be done by some concerned user of said platform (read 'you'), rather than the developer. <p> I'm aware that not everyone has the deps that I use, which is why there's a nice list of hyperlinks positioned pretty prominently on the webpage. They're also very quick indeed to install, being mostly rather mature packages with reliable make,make install type procedures. All the SDL ones are also mainstream enough for most distributions to include packages. Anyone who can figure out how to build excido can build any of the deps. <p> >can we have support for some alternatives that may be available in the system? Well, no. Supporting a bunch of different libraries defeats the purpose of abstracting something away into a library. Naturally anyone that wants to do it themselves is welcome to, but supporting a bunch of libraries that I'm not familiar with is a hell of a lot of effort. <p> In conclusion, I believe that free software is best made available by the developer as individual packages. That's why there's so much focus on dependancy management in the packaging system of any modern linux distro. Packaging stuff with everything else bundled in makes for a bloated system, and only makes sense for very large pieces of software, proprietary vendors, or those wishing to put special effort into the promotion of their software. <p> Having said all that, if you wished to produce an all-in binary tarball, I would certainly be happy to link to it from the excido page. <p> Hope that answers your question :-) | 2003-11-28 11:10:20 | 15384 |
| 15476 | FooBillard | games | -1 | Re: Great! | 1) hmm, didnt miss that till now, but ill think about it. 2) i will consider this cause the direct cue view always led to confusion somehow.<br> 3) try F2 <br> 4) in non-cue-view (F3) this is the case already <br> | 2003-11-28 14:32:11 | 15410 |
| 15477 | Amphetamine | games | -1 | Re: Amphetamine | yeah, cool game... but lava part too hard! please tell me how to get through it! | 2003-11-28 17:43:27 | 1912 |
| 15478 | Pathological | games | 8689 | Re: Greeeeeat | Agreed. Wonderful game. 5 stars without doubt from me. :) | 2003-11-28 22:36:10 | 14198 |